Measurement and design 5 MIN READ

Feedforward does not replace feedback

A model can supply an expected command before error develops. The remaining question is what happens when that expectation is wrong.

A model can supply an expected command before error develops. The remaining question is what happens when that expectation is wrong.

01 / FIELD NOTE

Predict the input before chasing error

A known static load can suggest a useful command before a sensor reports error. In the lab, nominal plant gain is one, so reference feedforward F=1 supplies the static input expected for r=1. With proportional feedback kₚ=2, adding that term corrects nominal reference offset. It is a model-based contribution, not feedback reacting faster.

02 / FIELD NOTE

Ask two separate performance questions

Record the 5 s tracking-error prediction and change F from 0 to 1. Then start a new prediction using disturbance increment at 12 s, choose “Stay about the same”, and change F back. Both outcomes can be correct: the reference numerator changed, but the disturbance path denominator did not. Pin both totals and use the separate disturbance trace to avoid mistaking a shifted baseline for better rejection.

03 / FIELD NOTE

Keep the model error visible

With F=1 and β=1, change actual K to 0.7. The nominal correction no longer delivers exact tracking. In this P-only example the final reference output is 0.875, so feedforward cannot substitute for integral correction or a better model. Two degrees of freedom means separate reference and feedback paths; it does not mean two independent physical actuators or unlimited control authority.

TAKEAWAY

Feedforward uses a model; it does not measure accumulated error like an integrator. In this P-only bench, changing beta also changes final tracking. A stable unsaturated two-degree-of-freedom PI controller can instead use integral action to restore constant-target accuracy. Do not confuse the two implementations.