THEORY BEHIND EXPERIMENT 02 · DC MOTOR

Open-loop speed drop under load, worked out

In the lab you pin a held-voltage run and a feedback run and watch them part at 4 s. Here the same comparison is done on paper first: one steady-state line predicts both the open-loop speed after the load and the voltage feedback must find, and a third case shows the limit feedback cannot cross.

Companion to the lab experiment Open loop versus closed loop. Run it there; this note predicts what you will see and why.

The model in play

The same two-state motor (R = 2 Ω, L = 0.12 H, Kₑ = Kₜ = 0.05, J = 0.002 kg·m², b = 0.0005 N·m·s) starts from rest with no load. A persistent 0.04 N·m load step arrives at 4 s. In open loop the command is a held 7 V and the 100 rad/s target is only a comparison line; in feedback the default PID (kp = 0.22, ki = 0.6, kd = 0.008) acts on the speed error every 20 ms.

Li˙=V−Ri−Keω,Jω˙=Kti−bω−τloadL\dot{i}=V-Ri-K_e\omega,\qquad J\dot{\omega}=K_t i-b\omega-\tau_{load}
open loop: V=7 V;feedback: V=sat⁡±12(PID(r−ω));τload=0.04⋅1[t≥4]\text{open loop: } V=7\ \mathrm{V};\qquad \text{feedback: } V=\operatorname{sat}_{\pm 12}\big(\mathrm{PID}(r-\omega)\big);\qquad \tau_{load}=0.04\cdot\mathbf{1}[t\ge 4]

Simplifications that matter here

  • The steady-state line ignores the transient. The motor's slow mode has a time constant of 1.10 s, so after a change it needs several seconds to reach the predicted speed.
  • The load enters as a torque on the rotor, not as a change of the speed measurement.

Predict it by hand

Setting both derivatives to zero gives one line for any steady state: V = 0.07ω + 40τ. Read it two ways. With V held at 7 V it gives the speed, before and after the load. With the target speed fixed it gives the voltage feedback must reach.

Vss=(Ke+RbKt)ω+RKtτload=0.07 ω+40 τloadV_{ss}=\Big(K_e+\frac{Rb}{K_t}\Big)\omega+\frac{R}{K_t}\tau_{load}=0.07\,\omega+40\,\tau_{load}
ωol=70.07=100.00 rad/s → τ=0.04  7−40×0.040.07=77.14 rad/s\omega_{ol}=\frac{7}{0.07}=100.00\ \mathrm{rad/s}\ \xrightarrow{\ \tau=0.04\ }\ \frac{7-40\times 0.04}{0.07}=77.14\ \mathrm{rad/s}
Vfb=0.07×100+40×0.04=8.60 VV_{fb}=0.07\times 100+40\times 0.04=8.60\ \mathrm{V}

Check against the engine

The feedback run ends at 100.00 rad/s with 8.60 V, both as predicted. The open-loop run reads 77.16 rad/s at 12 s, 0.02 rad/s above the predicted 77.14: eight seconds after the load the slow mode still has e^(−8/1.10) of its 22.86 rad/s drop left to go. Feedback is not instant either: the closed loop dips to 96.22 rad/s before the integral has raised the voltage above its pre-load 7 V.

What to change next

  1. Hold 8.6 V in open loop instead of 7 V.

    It is the right voltage for the loaded motor, but only for that load. Before 4 s the unloaded motor heads for 8.6/0.07 = 122.86 rad/s (the engine is at 119.45 rad/s when the load arrives), and afterwards it settles at 100.01 rad/s by 12 s. An open-loop command is calibrated for one disturbance.

  2. In feedback, make the load step 0.15 N·m.

    Holding 100 rad/s now needs 7 + 40 × 0.15 = 13 V, more than the limit, so even feedback stops at (12 − 40 × 0.15)/0.07 = 85.71 rad/s at most. The engine ends at 84.96 rad/s with 11.95 V: the anti-windup rule refuses any integral step that would push the request past 12 V, so the request parks just below the limit and the speed stays 0.75 rad/s under the ceiling.

Common mistakes when reading this run

  • Treating the target line as an open-loop command. The held voltage never reads it; it is there to measure the 22.86 rad/s shortfall.
  • Saying feedback makes the motor stiffer. The motor's own response to the load is unchanged; feedback recovers by raising the voltage, which you see in Control effort.
  • Assuming feedback can absorb any load. Every load above (12 − 7)/40 = 0.125 N·m costs speed at this target.

Where to go next

Run this experiment in the lab, pin a run and try the two changes above.

Lectures

Terms used in this note