Open loop versus closed loop
Lecture: Open loop and closed loop: why feedback? →At 4 s, a load increases. Which command reacts to the resulting speed error? Predict first ↓
TRYPin the closed-loop run. Switch to Open loop at 7 V without changing any other setting, then open Control effort. Pin that run too and compare at the same replay time.
Step response
Click the chart or move the time slider to replay.
Pin a run, change one setting, then compare the traces.
All three use the target speed as the reference, not the final speed. Rise: first 10% to first 90% of the target. Overshoot: peak speed above the target, as a percentage of the target, so a run that stops short of the target shows 0%. Settling: first recorded time after which the speed stays within ±2% of the target until the end, including any load events; “Not settled” if it is outside the band at the end. Defined for a positive target only.
At 4 s, a load increases. Which command reacts to the resulting speed error?
02 / CHECK YOUR PREDICTIONDid the result match your prediction?
Open to record a baseline
Did the result match your prediction?
Choose a measurable prediction before changing a setting. Record the current result, change one condition, then check. This compares complete recordings, not the replay cursor.
Waiting for a complete, valid result. A stopped run or unavailable metric cannot be judged; choose another measure if needed.
Prediction and baseline stay in memory for this page only. Use Start a new prediction to choose a new baseline.Frequency workbenchExplore the small-signal motor speed loop behind this controller setting.
Open loop versus closed loop
Read field notesLecture: Open loop and closed loop: why feedback? →Related Field Journal →Printable worksheet →
Termsopen-loop controlclosed-loop controldisturbance
Choose a prediction above before comparing the result.
Compare speed and applied voltage before and after the 4 s load. Both runs start from rest, use a 100 rad/s comparison target, and share the same motor and persistent 0.04 N·m load event.
Pin the closed-loop run. Switch to Open loop at 7 V without changing any other setting, then open Control effort. Pin that run too and compare at the same replay time.
The large number is the gain; the smaller number is that term’s output at the replay cursor. Change one gain, then pin and compare the run.