EIGENROOMLAB WORKSHEET 28Thermal control
Match heat loss with PI
NameSectionDate
Goal
Find which part of a PI controller supplies the heat a room keeps losing, and compare PI with an ON-OFF relay.
Setup
Lab eigenroom.com/lab/thermal?lesson=thermal-pi · short link eigenroom.com/thermal-pi
Open it on a phone or a computer; there is nothing to log in to or install. The link loads run A's settings:
- Heat capacity C
- 1000 J/K
- Heat loss H
- 5 W/K
- Ambient Ta
- 20 °C
- Initial temperature
- 20 °C
- Target temperature
- 60 °C
- Maximum heater
- 400 W
- Controller
- PI
- Kp
- 20 W/K
- Ki
- 0.1 W/(K·s)
- Conditional anti-windup
- On
- Event
- No event
- Duration
- 900 s
- APreset, exactly as the link opens it.
- BChange only: Ki → 0 W/(K·s).
- CChange only: Controller → ON-OFF.
Pin each run before you change a setting, so you can compare runs at the same replay time.
1. Predict
At the target the temperature error is zero, but the room still removes heat. Which part of PI can supply the needed power?
Write your prediction and a reason before you run anything.
2. Observe
Read each value in the lab and write it in the table.
| Quantity | Where to read it | A | B | C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Temperature at t = 900 s (°C) | Readout at 900 s | |||
| Applied power at t = 900 s (W) | Readout at 900 s | |||
| Integral term at t = 900 s (W) | Readout at 900 s | |||
| Time within ±1 °C (%) | Results below the plots |
3. Explain
Run B settles below the target. Use the applied power at the end to explain the offset.
In run A, which term supplies the heater power at the end?
The ON-OFF run spends more of its time within ±1 °C than PI. Is it the better controller?
Extension (optional)
Raise Ki to 0.3 W/(K·s). Does the PI run reach the band sooner, and at what cost?