Signals in practice 5 MIN READ

Which error is your feedback actually reducing?

A sensor gain can make a small summing-junction error coexist with a large physical tracking error.

Before increasing gain, write down what the sensor reports. The controller sees the measured signal; a number called “error” may not mean the physical target minus the output.

01 / FIELD NOTE

One change that exposes the distinction

Open Block algebra, choose Negative feedback, and keep G₁=2 and G₂=3. At H=1, y=6/7 and both errors equal 1/7. Record a prediction that output will decrease, then set H=2 and check it. The output becomes 6/13≈0.462. The summing error is 1/13≈0.077, while physical tracking error is 7/13≈0.538.

02 / FIELD NOTE

The loop is doing what it was wired to do

The summing point computes e=r−Hy. Substituting y=G₁G₂e gives y=G₁G₂r/(1+G₁G₂H). A smaller e does not imply smaller r−y unless the sensor and reference share the intended scale. In a speed loop this can happen when rpm, rad/s and a sensor voltage are mixed without explicit calibration.

03 / FIELD NOTE

A practical debugging order

Write the units at every wire. Check the sensor conversion, the reference scale and the summing sign before changing gains. Reproduce the same input after calibration. This bench uses static gains, so it isolates scaling; dynamic stability still requires the plant and controller poles.

TAKEAWAY

Compare r−y and r−Hy before declaring tracking success.

PUT IT TO THE TEST

From reading to a repeatable run.