Stability checks 5 MIN READ

Positive coefficients are not a stability certificate

A cubic with positive coefficients can still have two growing modes.

A quick sign check is useful, but stopping there can approve an unstable design. Routh makes the missing condition visible before a time simulation hides it behind a short recording.

01 / FIELD NOTE

Cross the boundary with one coefficient

Set a=2, b=3, c=4 in the Routh lab. Predict that the right-half-plane root count will increase, record the baseline, and move c to 8. The first column changes from [1,2,1,4] to [1,2,−1,8]. Two sign changes reveal two unstable roots even though the original polynomial coefficients remain positive.

02 / FIELD NOTE

Zero unstable roots does not mean strict stability

At c=6 the polynomial factors as (s+2)(s²+3). There are no strictly right-half-plane roots, but the pair ±j√3 lies on the boundary. The zero row and boundary message matter as much as the root count. At c=0 an origin pole gives another non-asymptotic case. Do not convert either case into a “stable” checkbox.

03 / FIELD NOTE

After the stability check

For this positive-a/b family, strict stability requires 0<c<ab. Then inspect how close poles are to the imaginary axis and whether the response meets settling and effort requirements. Routh counts unstable roots; it does not measure gain margin, phase margin or robustness to an uncertain physical parameter.

TAKEAWAY

Inspect boundary modes as well as sign changes.

PUT IT TO THE TEST

From reading to a repeatable run.