Design practice 6 MIN READ

Which RLC resonance did you measure?

Must the largest capacitor-voltage response occur exactly at ωn = 1/√(LC)?

With L = 1, C = 0.0625 and R = 1, ωn = 4 rad/s and ζ = 0.125. The capacitor-voltage gain peaks near 3.94 rad/s; series-current magnitude peaks at 4 rad/s. The measured quantity matters. At zero resistance and exact natural frequency, a nonzero sine has no bounded sinusoidal steady state.

01 / FIELD NOTE

Make one fair comparison

Pin a 1 V sine at 1 rad/s. Change only frequency to 3.94, then 8 rad/s. Compare late capacitor voltage and current. Startup transients remain part of a finite recording.

Before moving a setting, write which signal you expect to change and why. A faster-looking curve alone does not explain the mechanism. Keep the initial state and all other settings visible in the pinned run.

02 / FIELD NOTE

Resonance depends on the output you ask about

For positive R, series-current magnitude reaches its maximum at 1/√(LC). Capacitor-voltage magnitude instead peaks at ωn√(1−2ζ²) only when 0<ζ<1/√2. With ζ=0.125, the voltage peak is around 3.94 rad/s rather than 4. A measured output includes its own scaling and frequency dependence; do not label every maximum simply as the natural frequency.

A short sine experiment contains the forced response and the initial transient. With zero resistance, the transient does not decay; at exact natural frequency the nonzero sinusoidal input produces growing oscillations and no bounded steady-state amplitude. Compare the end of matched-duration recordings and explain the assumptions before reading a peak as a frequency-response gain.

03 / FIELD NOTE

What to change next

Specify both the input and the measured output before quoting a resonant frequency. Compare capacitor voltage with current under identical excitation. If the record is too short for transients to decay, report that limitation instead of treating the visible maximum as a steady-state gain.

TAKEAWAY

With L = 1, C = 0.0625 and R = 1, ωn = 4 rad/s and ζ = 0.125. The capacitor-voltage gain peaks near 3.94 rad/s; series-current magnitude peaks at 4 rad/s. The measured quantity matters. At zero resistance and exact natural frequency, a nonzero sine has no bounded sinusoidal steady state.

CHECK YOUR UNDERSTANDING: Must the largest capacitor-voltage response occur exactly at ωn = 1/√(LC)?

With L = 1, C = 0.0625 and R = 1, ωn = 4 rad/s and ζ = 0.125. The capacitor-voltage gain peaks near 3.94 rad/s; series-current magnitude peaks at 4 rad/s. The measured quantity matters. At zero resistance and exact natural frequency, a nonzero sine has no bounded sinusoidal steady state.

PUT IT TO THE TEST

From reading to a repeatable run.