EIGENROOMLAB WORKSHEET 30ANSWER KEY · FOR INSTRUCTORSThermal control
Off does not mean cold
Goal
Show that a heater cannot cool, and measure passive cooling with the time constant τ = C/H.
Setup
Lab eigenroom.com/lab/thermal?lesson=passive-cooling · short link eigenroom.com/passive-cooling
Open it on a phone or a computer; there is nothing to log in to or install. The link loads run A's settings:
- Heat capacity C
- 1000 J/K
- Heat loss H
- 5 W/K
- Ambient Ta
- 20 °C
- Initial temperature
- 80 °C
- Target temperature
- 30 °C
- Maximum heater
- 400 W
- Controller
- PI
- Kp
- 20 W/K
- Ki
- 0.1 W/(K·s)
- Conditional anti-windup
- On
- Event
- No event
- Duration
- 900 s
- APreset, exactly as the link opens it.
- BChange only: Kp → 80 W/K.
- CChange only: Heat loss H → 10 W/K.
- DChange only: Target temperature → 15 °C. (ext.)
1. Predict
Start at 80 °C and ask for 30 °C. Can increasing Kp make cooling faster once heater power is already zero?
At zero applied power, T = Ta + (T0 − Ta) exp(−t/τ), with τ = C/H. Larger Kp cannot make the input negative. Larger H speeds passive cooling but also raises the power needed to hold a warm target. This lumped model has no heater residual heat, sensor lag or transport delay; it is not an oven safety simulator.
2. Observe
| Quantity | Where to read it | A | B | C | D ext. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Time constant τ = C/H (s) | Settings panel | 200.00 s | 200.00 s | 100.00 s | 200.00 s |
| Requested power at t = 100 s (W) | Readout at 100 s | -527.84 W | -2111.35 W | -241.46 W | -827.84 W |
| Applied power at t = 100 s (W) | Readout at 100 s | 0.00 W | 0.00 W | 0.00 W | 0.00 W |
| Temperature at t = 100 s (°C) | Readout at 100 s | 56.39 °C | 56.39 °C | 42.07 °C | 56.39 °C |
| Temperature at t = 200 s (°C) | Readout at 200 s | 42.07 °C | 42.07 °C | 28.45 °C | 42.07 °C |
| Gap left to ambient at t = 200 s, (T − Ta)/(T0 − Ta) (%) | Readout at 200 s | 36.79% | 36.79% | 14.09% | 36.79% |
Values computed by Thermal engine 1.0.0 at the settings above. A replay readout can differ in the last digit if the slider is not exactly at the stated time; values read from a plot are approximate.
3. Explain
Why are runs A and B identical during the first 200 s?
Both request negative power (-527.84 W and -2111.35 W at 100 s), but a heater cannot cool: the applied power is 0.00 W in both, so the body cools passively at the same rate.
Check run A at t = τ: how much of the initial gap to ambient is left?
τ = 200.00 s; at 200 s the temperature is 42.07 °C, so 36.79% of the gap remains, close to e⁻¹ as T = Ta + (T0 − Ta)e^(−t/τ) predicts.
Run C doubles the heat loss. What changes besides faster cooling?
τ halves to 100.00 s, so it reaches 28.45 °C by 200 s. But holding a warm target now needs more power: 100.00 W at the target against 50.00 W.
Extension (optional)
Set the target to 15 °C, below ambient. What does the controller do, and where does the temperature end?
It keeps requesting negative power the heater cannot give. The temperature approaches ambient and ends -5.67 °C from the target: a target below ambient cannot be held with heating alone.