EIGENROOMLAB WORKSHEET 27ANSWER KEY · FOR INSTRUCTORSThermal control
Give the thermostat a band
Goal
Measure how a thermostat's hysteresis band trades relay switching against temperature swing.
Setup
Lab eigenroom.com/lab/thermal?lesson=thermostat · short link eigenroom.com/thermostat
Open it on a phone or a computer; there is nothing to log in to or install. The link loads run A's settings:
- Heat capacity C
- 1000 J/K
- Heat loss H
- 5 W/K
- Ambient Ta
- 20 °C
- Initial temperature
- 20 °C
- Target temperature
- 60 °C
- Maximum heater
- 400 W
- Controller
- ON-OFF
- Total hysteresis band
- 2 °C
- Event
- No event
- Duration
- 900 s
- APreset, exactly as the link opens it.
- BChange only: Total hysteresis band → 0 °C.
- CChange only: Total hysteresis band → 6 °C.
1. Predict
A heater can only be fully on or off. How can it maintain 60 °C when 400 W is too much and 0 W is too little?
This model needs 5 × (60 − 20) = 200 W at the target. ON-OFF control alternates 400 W and 0 W. With a 2 °C band it turns on at 59 °C, off at 61 °C, and remembers its state between them. A wider band usually reduces transitions here but permits a larger temperature swing. Even a zero band switches only at the fixed 1 s controller ticks; it is not an infinitely fast relay.
2. Observe
| Quantity | Where to read it | A | B | C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Relay transitions | Results below the plots | 69 | 761 | 25 |
| Temperature swing, 600–900 s (max − min) (°C) | Plot, with the replay cursor | 2.20 °C | 0.20 °C | 6.19 °C |
| Time within ±1 °C (%) | Results below the plots | 77.51% | 85.14% | 27.78% |
| Heater energy (Wh) | Results below the plots | 57.56 Wh | 57.67 Wh | 58.56 Wh |
Values computed by Thermal engine 1.0.0 at the settings above. A replay readout can differ in the last digit if the slider is not exactly at the stated time; values read from a plot are approximate.
3. Explain
How does the band trade relay transitions against temperature swing?
Run B (0 °C band): 761 transitions and a 0.20 °C swing late in the run. Run A (2 °C): 69 and 2.20 °C. Run C (6 °C): 25 and 6.19 °C. A wider band switches less but lets the temperature wander further.
Why does even the zero band not hold the target exactly?
The relay can switch only at the 1 s controller ticks, and the heater is either 400 W or off while the target needs 200.00 W. Between ticks the temperature keeps moving, so a 0.20 °C swing remains.
Extension (optional)
Heater energy hardly changes between the three runs. Why does the band not change energy use much?
Over a long run the heater must replace the heat lost near the target, 200.00 W at the target itself, so the energies are close: 57.56 Wh, 57.67 Wh and 58.56 Wh. The wide band ends warmer (final error -2.88 °C), which costs a little more.