EXPERIMENT 23 / MOTOR LAB

Raising P usually makes a motor loop react faster. Will it shrink the dip below zero here? Predict first ↓

TRYPin this run, raise P from 0.15 to 0.30, then try 0.40.

REPLAYABLE SIMULATIONCALCULATING… / M-01
SPEED—TARGET20 rad/s
t = 0.00 s / 12.00 s
OSCILLOSCOPE / MEASURED RESPONSE

Step response

Loading plot…

Click the chart or move the time slider to replay.

TARGET20 rad/s
Actual—
Requested—
Applied—
Error now—
PINNED RUNS 0/3

Pin a run, change one setting, then compare the traces.

Rise, 10–90% of target—
Overshoot vs target—
Settling, ±2% of target—
Final error—
Control effort—

All three use the target speed as the reference, not the final speed. Rise: first 10% to first 90% of the target. Overshoot: peak speed above the target, as a percentage of the target, so a run that stops short of the target shows 0%. Settling: first recorded time after which the speed stays within ±2% of the target until the end, including any load events; “Not settled” if it is outside the band at the end. Defined for a positive target only.

01 / PREDICT

Raising P usually makes a motor loop react faster. Will it shrink the dip below zero here?

What do you predict?
02 / CHECK YOUR PREDICTION

Did the result match your prediction?

Open to record a baseline

Choose a measurable prediction before changing a setting. Record the current result, change one condition, then check. This compares complete recordings, not the replay cursor.

Waiting for a complete, valid result. A stopped run or unavailable metric cannot be judged; choose another measure if needed.

Prediction and baseline stay in memory for this page only. Use Start a new prediction to choose a new baseline.
Frequency workbenchExplore the small-signal motor speed loop behind this controller setting.
FIELD NOTE / 23

The wrong-way start

Read field notes

Termsright-half-plane zerophase marginPID control

YOUR PREDICTION

Choose a prediction above before comparing the result.

WHAT TO WATCH

This motor has a right-half-plane zero at s = +5 rad/s. Replay the first 0.3 s: the speed falls below zero before it rises. Compare the dip, overshoot and phase margin as P grows.

Pin this run, raise P from 0.15 to 0.30, then try 0.40.

CURRENT SETTINGS / LIVE SIGNAL
P 0.15 —I 0.15 —D 0 —

The large number is the gain; the smaller number is that term’s output at the replay cursor. Change one gain, then pin and compare the run.

PProportional0.150